Identity Commons Logo

The Identity Commons logo is a mashup of the letters “i” and “c”, and it represents two ideas. The first is the notion of an upside-down umbrella. Identity Commons was founded on the notion that it would empower bottoms-up work, rather than organize itself from the top-down. The upside-down umbrella metaphor reflects that.

The second idea is a one-eyed smiley. As Meng Weng Wong, who conceived of this logo, explained:

In Book 9 of Homer’s Odyssey, a scouting party led by Odysseus lands on the Island of the Cyclopes and discovers a large cave. They enter into the cave and feast on food they find there. This cave is the home of Polyphemus, who soon returns and traps the trespassers in the cave. He proceeds to eat several crew members, but Odysseus devises a cunning plan for escape.

To make Polyphemus unwary, Odysseus gives him a skin of very strong, unwatered wine. When Polyphemus asks for Odysseus’ name, he tells him that it is ‘Outis’, Greek for ‘no man’ or ‘nobody’. Once the giant falls asleep drunk, Odysseus and his men take the spit from the fire and drive it through Polyphemus’ only eye. Polyphemus’ cries of help are answered by the others of his race; however, they turn away from aiding him when they hear that “Nobody” is the cause of his woes.

This being the first recorded case of a security breach due to the lack of an identity management infrastructure, I hope that the Gentle Reader will forgive me for the visual pun: your upside-down umbrella is also a one-i’ed smiley.

As would be expected, this logo emerged from the efforts of several members of our community. Paul Trevithick drove the process and engaged with the designer to produce several iterations. Kaliya Hamlin suggested basing the logo around the upside-down umbrella metaphor. Meng Weng Wong built off of Kaliya’s idea and introduced the Cyclops metaphor.

The First Internet Identity Workshop

We brought together all of the projects we knew about touching on key aspects of innovating user-centric identity. This was our invitation:

The Internet Identity Workshop focuses on identity in the large. Providing identity services between people, websites, and organizations that may or may not have any kind of formalized relationship is a different problem than providing authentication and authorization services within a single organization. Many have argued that the lack of a credible identity infrastructure will eventually result in the Internet being so overrun with fraud as to make it useless for many interesting uses.

To solve this problem, or pieces of it, companies and individuals have made a variety of architectural and governance proposals. Some of these include (they are all linked back to the pages viewable in October 2005):

The goal of the Internet Identity Workship is to provide a forum to disucss these and other architectural and governance proposals for Internet-wide identity services and their underlying philosophies. The workshop will comprise a day of presentations on Internet-scale identity architectures followed by a day of structured open space to accommodate the range of topics and issues that will emerge from day one and other issues and identity services that do not fit into the scope of the formal

Day 1 had these presentations

8:45 Identity in the Marketplace: The Rise of the Fully Empowered Customer Doc Searls
9:30 Use Cases for the Social Web Mary Ruddy, SocialPhysics
10:15 Break
10:45 Microsoft's Vision for an Identity Metasystem Mike Jones, Microsoft
11:30 Liberty Alliance Overview Brett McDowell, Liberty Alliance
     
1:30 XRI Metaidentifiers Drummond Reed
2:15 Identity 2.0 Design Guidelines and the Evolution of the SXIP Protocol Dick Hardt, SXIP
3:00 Decentralized, REST-ful Digital Identity with LID Johannes Ernst, NetMesh
     
4:15 OpenID Brad Fitzpatrick, LiveJournal
5:00 SocialPhysics And The Higgins Trust Framework Paul Trevithick, SocialPhysics
5:45 Identity Commons Owen Davis & Joel Getzendanner

Day 2 we used Open Space Technology to support conversation and innovation amongst the participants that gathered.  There were some topics and papers that were put forward ahead of time as potential topics.

The schedule made live at the event included these sessions

Photos from the first IIW are on Phil's Blog and Flickr

Blog posts about the event can be found here.

Podcast from IIW Conclusion MP3

The original identity gang

I vividly remember the first time the identity gang met – it was in at Digital Identity World in October of 2004.  I had met Doc Searls in August at Linux world and shared about the work that Owen Davis, Drummond Reed, Bill Washburn and others were doing trying open standards for individuals.  The meeting attracted many people who were interested in this new way of thinking about how individuals could have portable autonomous identity. It lead to the mailing list – and the identity gang podcast on the Gilmor Gang Show January 31st.

From there we met at other conferences including PCForum and the Burton Group.  Doc encouraged many of the community to begin blogging.  We had the first Internet Identity Workshop in 2005 and the 2nd Identity Gang Podcast on January 30th 2005.